Work in progress (dec-2024)
Last update: September 2025
Product list
List of virtualization platforms to completely or partially replace VMware Sphere (aimed at “any” enterprise environment besides “small”)
Vendor / Product | HV | Notes |
---|---|---|
“The big boys” | ||
IBM RedHat OpenShift / OKD | kvm | ➡ k8s ➡ has vm addon “OpenShift Virtualization” ➡ based on KubeVirt operator |
Oracle Virtualization (VM Server and Linux KVM) | kvm | ➡ Oracle Linux KVM is based on oVirt |
Nutanix Cloud Platform | ahv | |
OpenStack | multiple | ➡ complex to setup and maintain |
Apache CloudStack | multiple | ➡ OSS ✖ needs specific hardware |
Azure Local | hyperv | ➡ run vm’s and select azure services onprem ➡ formerly “azure stack hci” |
XCP-ng | xen | ➡ XenServer fork (Vates offers Support) ✔ management appliance available (“XO”) ✖ product seems “unfinished” at best |
“Second tier“ | ||
Proxmox Virtual Environment | kvm | ➡ uses debian, linux, novnc etc ✖ seems to be aimed at smaller env’s ✖ outdated management webui |
OpenNebula | kvm | ➡ touted as vcloud replacement ✔ webui, user/tenant self service |
Virtuozzo Hybrid Infrastructure | multiple | ➡ based on openstack |
Harvester HCI | kvm | ➡ built on k8s (+ kubevirt) ➡ formerly “suse virtualization” |
“New / lesser-known“ | ||
Sangfor HCI | xen | ➡ chinese company |
VergeOS | kvm | |
Scale Computing | kvm | |
Triton | kvm | ➡ originally developed by Joyent ➡ solaris/illumos based |
Platform 9 | kvm | |
HPE VM Essentials | kvm |
Not included: public cloud
Shortlist
Currently it seems migrating to RedHat’s OCP (and OCPv) is a popular option.
In general, Kubernetes with KubeVirt is a solid choice. The KubeVirt project was initiated in 2016 by RedHat to run KVM vm’s as native k8s objects. Besides OCP there are multiple other products available such as Harvester or “vanilla” k8s.
It benefits from the large k8s landscape (storage, networking etc). Also, combining k8s with kubevirt makes it possible to run both containers and vm’s in a cluster (on bare metal) with somewhat similar functionality as VMware Tanzu.
Ecosystem
Everything else besides VMware’s ESX Hypervisor & vSphere like vSAN, vCenter, PowerCLI and Aria (Automation, Operations, Logs/vRLI). Similar tooling and automation offered by these alternatives or other 3rd party replacements.
Storage
Options to replace vSAN / switch to NAS or SAN:
- SDS: CEPH, Cloudian, Starwind VSAN or zVault (NAS)
- Hardware: DDN/Trintri (NAS), NetApp (NAS), TrueNAS, Pure Storage, HPE, IBM or Dell
Management
- Azure Local: like cloud (Arc control plane)
- XCP-NG: Xen Orchestra (multiple hosts)
- Harvester: Rancher
- ManageIQ can manage OpenStack and OpenShift/K8s platforms
IaC
Scripting
- Azure Local: PowerShell
- XCP-ng: xe cli tool (local)
- ProxmoxVE: Bash(?)
Backup
- Veeam supports Hyper-V, Proxmox VE and XCP-NG, their product Kasten supports Kubernetes
- Commvault supports Proxmox VE (but not Kubernetes)
Logging
A few “DIY” centralized logging examples are Elastic (ELK stack), InfluxDB (TICK stack), Grafana Loki, Splunk and GrayLog
API
- Proxmox VE API (REST). Clients: most popular languages
- OpenNebula API (XML-RPC), Clients: Java, Go …
- Nutanix REST APIs and SDK (Python, Java, Go, JS)
- OpenShift: API based on k8s
- XCP-ng: “XAPI” or Orchestra API
- CloudStack API
- Azure Local API (REST)
- Kubernetes (OCP, Harvester, KubeVirt)
More information
Links
- https://www.theregister.com/Tag/VMWare
- https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=vmware+alternative
- https://veducate.co.uk/kubevirt-for-vsphere-admins-deep-dive-guide/
Gartner’s Magic Quadrant
From research reports, to get an idea about market trends
Hyperconverged Infrastructure Software
File and Object Storage Platforms
You must be logged in to post a comment.